About HILC Weekly Column News Media Library Make a Donation Online Store
In The News:
Home > Weekly Column
Weekly Column

The Morning After Pill: Kills "Common" Sense!
By Harry R. Jackson, Jr.
Post Your Comments
June 9,2013

On April 5, a Federal District Court, Judge Edward Korman, overruled an important decision of the Secretary of Health and Human Services, Kathleen Sebelius, ordering that Plan B One-Step (often referred to as the "Morning After" pill) be made available over the counter for anyone 15 years of age or older. Just this past week on Wednesday June 5, a federal appeals court took the following steps according to Larry Neumeister and Lauran Neergaard in a USA Today article: "The brief order issued by the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan permitted two-pill versions of emergency contraception to immediately be sold without restrictions, but the court refused to allow unrestricted sales of Plan B One-Step until it decides the merits of the government's appeal."


Sebelius had overruled a FDA decision to make the Morning After Pill available to girls as young as 15. This meant that Plan B would continue to require a prescription for girls 16 and younger and that girls 17 and older would need to show proof of age to the pharmacist to purchase it. The nation was shocked when a male judge (Edward Korman) ignored the oversight of the Secretary of Health and Human Services.

High School girls should not be able to use powerful morning-after drugs without conferring with their parents, guardians, or doctors. This kind of purchase is not the constitutional right or moral privilege of a minor. Despite the increasingly younger ages at which our children are becoming sexually aware and then sexually active, the government should not usurp the parent's role or authority for many important reasons.

First, over-the-counter access to "emergency contraception" is a pimp's dream. This is a danger to females of all ages. Secondly, this kind of law may assist child sex trafficking in our country by helping to keep involuntary "sex slaves" on the street. Believe it or not, this is a huge problem in the Washington, DC area, in which I live. Illicit sex has long been known as the favorite intoxicant of the power mad DC crowd, but the sex slave business reaches the heartland as well. Last summer, the FBI arrested 104 pimps in 57 cities, all of whom were forcing girls between the ages of 13 and 17 into prostitution.

It seems that business interests in the drug's release are currently being considered before the welfare of the patients. The Korman ruling was surprising to many health care providers because hormonal birth control methods like this one presents special risks for women with other health issues such as diabetes, liver problems, and smoking. It is also generally understood that sexually active women need to be under the regular care of an obstetrician-gynecologist to ensure that their reproductive systems remain healthy and to have regular screenings for sexually transmitted diseases.

Proponents of the judge's ruling claim that the over-the-counter availability of Plan B would not disrupt the doctor-patient relationship. The measure, they claim, is only to allow responsible women to purchase Plan B on the weekends or holidays. The judge dismissed concerns for minors saying, "This case is not about the potential misuse of Plan B by 11-year-olds...the number of 11-year-olds using these drugs is likely to be miniscule..."

Contrary to the judge's concepts, even President Obama (in support of Sebelius) noted the possibility of misuse by children and the side effects of the drug. A Kaiser Permanente Study backs up the president's conclusions. It demonstrated that at least 8% of girls under 17 could be expected to use Plan B incorrectly. Misuse of this drug can result in an ectopic pregnancy, a dangerous condition which can cause hemorrhage or death. Common side effects of Plan B when used correctly include abnormal bleeding, nausea, lower abdominal pain, fatigue, headache, and dizziness. Any of these physical effects would concern a caring parent.

President Obama added questions about the judgment of the youngest users of this drug. He said simply: "The reason Kathleen ... could not be confident that a ten-year-old or an eleven-year-old going to a drugstore should be able - alongside bubble gum or batteries - to buy a medication that potentially, if not used properly, could have an adverse effect."

Most parents quickly assert that Judge Korman's decision is wrong! Abuse of this kind of drug in our era is inevitable. Consider this: the FDA decided recently not to approve any generic versions of the prescription painkiller OxyContin because they could be crushed into powder and snorted or injected, as the name-brand version was for many years. (OxyContin's manufacturers have been forced to develop a different kind of tablet in order to prevent abuse.)

How can we understand the dangers of OxyContin and miss the problems with the Morning After Pill. Ruling that the FDA should have no responsibility to restrict the sale of a drug that would endanger children - by empowering rapists, pedophiles, pimps, and sex traffickers to cover up their crimes - seems like a travesty of justice. The judge is out of touch with the culture. In fact, he needs a refresher course in Common Sense!

Show Your Support For Families
Be Empowered With Facts about Creating Wealth
Reform Education with Choices
Understand Healthcare in the US
Join Us As We Impact America!
Follow HILC Online